This weekend, I ticked an item off my bucket list.
I made an album and I shared it with some friends and family members!
It’s a self-titled album by a fictional band called The Pickpockets. The album cover is below. If you click on the image (or here), there is a website which has all of its songs.
I’ve wanted to make an album since my late teens.
If I’m honest, I’d actually given up on this dream until recently. In the words of Salman Rushdie, I had come to accept that “Not all possibilities are open to us. The world is finite; our hopes spill over its rim”.
Yet here I am. I’ve done it.
The songs are mine. One is for my wife. Several revolve around the conceit of time travel. One is called “I like your mum” and can be interpreted two very different ways. Most of the songs embrace absurdity in one way or another: the working phrase for this project was “nihilistic pop”. But some are a little more serious: one is a homage to Cormac McCarthy’s Blood Meridian.
I went to great pains to get the sound and most of the lyrics right. I articulated the sound that I wanted. Think: The Wombats, Lily Allen, The Kooks, and early Arctic Monkeys.
As I type this, it’s my favourite album of all time! Maybe I’m too close to it right now. I am curious how I will feel about the project in one or three years’ time.
Full disclosure:
I generated the music with the help of AI. For the music, I used Suno. (Which I have previously said makes me feel dirty. The current version, which I used, was trained from scratch using licensed music, which doesn’t entirely make me feel clean, but still.) There was a lot of trial and error. I spent a lot of time working on the song ideas, the style, and the lyrics. (And for this, I got Claude Code to help me. Gemini helped with the visuals.)
The response
My son refuses to listen, whether that’s because he can hear that it’s AI generated or has a general aversion to AI. My wife is ambivalent, although one song made her cry.
People have said “very listenable” and “pretty good not going to lie” and “catchy tunes”.
On the other hand, one person said “sloptastic” and that “its unlistenable to me”. They referred to “flat/dead production”, and to the vocals and lyrics falling into an uncanny valley.
I see where he’s coming from. If I took the project further there are lots of things I could and would do. One of them is having more consistent vocals across the songs. I would almost certainly record live instruments and vocals over some or all of the tracks. But I don’t hear what he does. I love it as it is, and for what I’d get out of spending more time on it: the juice isn’t worth the squeeze.
Would more effort have changed things?
I keep running a counterfactual where I played and sang every note, and didn’t use any AI as part of the project. Would more people have engaged?
I suspect so.
Having said that, I’ve always found it hard to get feedback about things, whether it relates to this blog or anything else. Maybe there’s something about me that means I can buy the tickets, but can’t get people excited about the ride.
On the other hand, what if I backed a truckload of money onto Max Martin’s front yard and got him to produce and co-write a bunch of songs? Nobody would say I didn’t make an album. It makes me wonder why a producer and studio musicians would be acceptable and AI models wouldn’t. I wonder whether the answer is that money and a famous name signal effort and taste, in a way that a Suno subscription cannot. But the songs would be no more mine.
Another form of Rorschach test
Different people have different feelings about AI. I believe a whole range of feelings are valid. In fact, my feelings can change massively over the course of a single day!
I have a hypothesis that AI-generated music gets more exaggerated feelings from people. My suspicion is that people who have an aversion to AI in general, or AI writing, are going to have an even stronger aversion to AI-generated music.
I have complicated feelings towards AI, but as I’ve said before – I think the toothpaste is out of the tube, and I think it enables amazing things.
You can argue all you like about whether I’ve actually “created” this album. That’s cool.
By my own standards, these songs didn’t exist before. They wouldn’t exist without my input and direction. These songs reflect my taste, and are a fresh, idiosyncratic reflection of who I am that I haven’t been able to capture in other mediums.
By my own standards, I have achieved something. I’ve ticked something off my bucket list.
It’s possible that I will have a different perspective in a few months’ or years’ time. Perhaps I’m too close to it, and I have an overly positive perspective on this technology.
For now – whatever your thoughts or feelings on the matter might be – I love this album, and I’m proud of it.
I’d love to hear your thoughts!


